When You Should Appeal a Tax Decision
If the IRS has proposed changes to your return, assessed additional tax, or denied a refund claim, you have the right to challenge that decision. The key is acting within the applicable deadlines and choosing the right appeal path for your situation.
- You disagree with an audit result. The examiner's findings are not final. You can request review by the independent Office of Appeals or petition Tax Court.
- You received a Notice of Deficiency. This 90-day letter is your ticket to Tax Court, where you can contest the IRS without paying the disputed tax first.
- You missed the original deadline. Audit reconsideration may allow you to reopen a closed case and present evidence the IRS never reviewed.
- You believe you do not owe the tax. A doubt-as-to-liability Offer in Compromise challenges the legal basis of the assessment itself.
Critical Deadlines
- 30 Days: Office of Appeals
- You typically have 30 days from a proposed assessment or 30-day letter to request an Appeals hearing.
- 90 Days: Tax Court Petition
- From the date of the Notice of Deficiency. This deadline is absolute and cannot be extended.
- No Fixed Deadline: Audit Reconsideration
- Available at any time, but acting sooner preserves more options and prevents further collection activity.
- Varies: Penalty Abatement
- Requests can generally be made at any time the penalty is outstanding. Earlier requests tend to be more successful.
How I Challenge Tax Decisions
Every tax dispute is different. I evaluate your situation and pursue the appeal path that offers the best chance of reducing or eliminating what you owe.
IRS Office of Appeals
An independent division within the IRS that reviews disputed tax matters. Appeals officers have broad authority to settle cases based on the hazards of litigation, often producing significantly better outcomes than the examination stage.
- Independent review separate from the examining agent
- Authority to settle based on litigation risk
- Available after a 30-day letter or proposed assessment
U.S. Tax Court Petition
If you receive a Notice of Deficiency (90-day letter), you have the right to petition the U.S. Tax Court to challenge the IRS before paying the disputed amount. This is often the most powerful tool available to taxpayers who disagree with an audit result.
- Contest the IRS without paying the tax first
- 90-day filing deadline from the Notice of Deficiency
- Most cases settle before trial through negotiation with IRS counsel
Audit Reconsideration
If you missed the deadline to respond to an audit or the IRS made changes to your return without your input, audit reconsideration allows you to reopen the case by presenting new information the IRS did not previously review.
- Available when you missed the original audit deadline
- Submit documentation the IRS did not previously consider
- Can reduce or eliminate an assessed deficiency
Doubt-as-to-Liability Offer in Compromise
Unlike the more common ability-to-pay Offer in Compromise, a doubt-as-to-liability OIC argues that you do not actually owe the tax the IRS has assessed. This is a direct challenge to the legal or factual basis of the tax debt itself.
- Disputes whether the tax is legally owed
- Based on legal arguments, not financial hardship
- Can eliminate the tax liability entirely if accepted
Penalty Abatement
IRS penalties can add 20% to 75% on top of the tax you owe. Penalty abatement requests ask the IRS to remove penalties based on reasonable cause, first-time penalty abatement, or statutory exceptions. This can save thousands of dollars.
- Reasonable cause: illness, disaster, reliance on professional advice
- First-time abatement for taxpayers with a clean compliance history
- Statutory exceptions for specific penalty types
State Tax Appeals
State tax authorities run their own assessment and appeals processes separate from the IRS. If a state department of treasury has proposed an assessment, denied a refund, or imposed penalties, you have the right to challenge that decision through administrative and judicial channels.
In Michigan, that path runs through the Department of Treasury, the Michigan Tax Tribunal, and the Michigan Court of Claims. Attorney James Maule represents taxpayers in these forums.
Informal Conference
After a proposed assessment from the Michigan Department of Treasury, you can request an informal conference to present your case before the assessment becomes final. This is often the fastest path to resolution.
Michigan Tax Tribunal
An independent administrative court that hears disputes over state income tax, property tax, and other state assessments. Filing a petition preserves your right to contest the assessment.
Michigan Court of Claims
For refund claims and certain other disputes, the Michigan Court of Claims has jurisdiction. The court applies Michigan tax law and can order Treasury to issue refunds or adjust assessments.
State Penalty and Interest Relief
Michigan imposes its own penalties and interest on unpaid tax. I pursue abatement of state penalties based on reasonable cause, voluntary disclosure, or compliance with payment arrangements.
Related Tax & Estate Services
Explore our other practice areas serving individuals, families, and small businesses across Michigan and nationwide.